Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Hemings. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Hemings. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, June 24, 2018

Jefferson, Hemings, and the Evolution of Racial Mixing

"A Philosophic Cock," 1804.  A Satirical Cartoon in a Federalist Newspaper of Jefferson's Relationship with Sally Hemings

A week ago, the Thomas Jefferson Foundation opened a new exhibit at Jefferson's Monticello plantation on Sally Hemings, Jefferson's slave who bore as many as six of his children over the last 40 years of his life.  The New York Times has a good article on this and also a good essay by Annette Gordon-Reed, who is one of the historians responsible for shifting scholarly opinion towards accepting Jefferson's fathering of Hemings' children.

That the principal author of the Declaration of Independence, who affirmed natural human equality and who denounced slavery as a violation of human nature, could not only own black slaves but also exploit them for his sexual gratification forces us to think about the human nature of slavery and the evolution of racial mixing.

Moreover, explaining the moral and political history of the Jefferson and Hemings relationship can illustrate the biopolitical science of political animals as moving through three levels of deep history--the universal history of the species, the cultural history of the group, and the individual history of animals within the group

In 1802, James Callender, a journalist with a grudge against Jefferson, published an article in a Richmond newspaper claiming that it was widely known in the neighborhood of Charlottesville that Jefferson had fathered several children with a slave woman named "Sally," and that these children bore a striking resemblance to Jefferson.  The Federalist opponents of Jefferson made this an issue in the presidential election of 1804.  Jefferson said nothing in public about this charge.  But some of his friends--including James Madison--dismissed it as preposterous, because it was contrary to the moral character that he had always displayed.

In 1853, however, Jefferson's friend John Hartwell Cocke wrote in his diary about "Mr. Jefferson's notorious example" as illustrating the shameful practice of slaveowners in Virginia fathering children with their slaves.

In the 1850s, Jefferson's grandson Thomas Jefferson Randolph spoke with the historian Henry S. Randall, telling him that Sally Hemings's children really did resemble his grandfather so closely that it was clear that the children had been fathered by someone in Jefferson's family.  But Randolph insisted that the father was Peter Carr, one of the sons of Jefferson's sister, who was notorious for his sexual connection with Sally Hemings.

In 1873, Sally Hemings's son Madison was interviewed by the editor of the Pike County Republican newspaper in Ohio.  He told the story of his ancestry as related to him by his mother.  He said that his grandmother (Elizabeth Hemings) had been fathered by an English sea captain, who had impregnated an African slave woman.  Elizabeth was owned by Virginian John Wayles, who took her as his concubine after the death of his wife.  He fathered Elizabeth's six children, one of whom was Sally Hemings.  One of Wayles' children by his wife was Martha, Thomas Jefferson's wife.  When Wayles died, Martha inherited his land and his slaves, including Sally Hemings, who was Martha's half-sister.

Martha died in 1782, and Jefferson promised her on her death bed that he would never remarry.  She had had six children, but only two daughters survived into adulthood--Martha and Maria.

In 1784, Jefferson was appointed a minister plenipotentiary to join John Adams and Benjamin Franklin in Europe to negotiate treaties.  In 1785, he was appointed to succeed Franklin as minister to France.  While in Paris, he was known for his flirtatious dalliances with married women, particularly Maria Cosway.

In 1787, the fourteen-year-old Sally Hemings accompanied the nine-year-old Maria Jefferson to Paris.  According to the accounts of slaves on the plantation and Jefferson's grandson, Sally was nearly white in appearance and so beautiful that she was known as "Dashing Sally."  According to Madison Hemmings's report, Sally in Paris became "Mr. Jefferson's concubine."  At this time, "concubine" was the term for a woman in an enduring sexual liaison with a man without being legally married to him.

In 1789, Jefferson was called back to the United States to become Secretary of State in President Washington's first administration.  Madison said that when Jefferson asked Sally to return home with him, she demurred, because she had learned enough French to know that French law would permit her to be free if she remained in France, while in Virginia she would be a slave.  Jefferson promised that if she returned with him, he would give her special privileges for the rest of her life, and her children would be freed at the age of 21.  Hemings trusted him to keep his word.  Jefferson was 46 years old.  Hemings was 16.

And, indeed, according to what Madison called "the treaty" between his mother and Jefferson, all four of the Hemings children who lived to adulthood--three sons (Beverly, Madison, and Eston) and one daughter (Harriet)--became free at adulthood.  All of the children worked in Jefferson's home and were free from any field work.  All of them married and raised children.  Beverly became identified as a white man, and he married a white woman.  Harriet became identified as a white woman and married a white man.  Eston lived as a white man who married a black woman.  Madison remained in the black community, and he married a fair skinned black woman.  After Jefferson's death in 1826, his slaves were sold, but Sally left the plantation and became a free woman, living with two of her children until her death in 1835.

It is not clear whether Hemings's sexual submission to Jefferson was romantic or coerced or perhaps some complex mixture of both.  At the new Monticello exhibit, some of the written displays use the word "rape?" with a question mark to convey this uncertainty about the character of their sexual relationship.

A few months after Madison Hemings's interview in 1873 with the Pike County Republican, Israel Jefferson, a former slave of Jefferson's and a friend of Hemings, gave his own interview to that newspaper confirming Hemings's story about his mother being Jefferson's concubine.

Until recently, however, historians have generally dismissed as unreliable all of the reports of Jefferson fathering children by Hemings.  Many historians have accepted the claim of Thomas Jefferson Randolph that the resemblance of Hemings's children to Jefferson could be explained by their being fathered by one of the Carr brothers.  Historians could not believe that a man with the moral character of Thomas Jefferson could have engaged in such reprehensible conduct in secret for almost 40 years.

In 1968, Winthrop Jordan, in his book White Over Black, noted that Jefferson's plantation account books showed that Jefferson had been at Monticello at every time when Sally Hemings conceived a child (Jordan 1968, 1999).  Later, it was shown that Hemings tended to get pregnant within one month after Jefferson's arrival at Monticello (Neiman 2000).

In 1974, Fawn Brodie published her best-selling popular book Thomas Jefferson: An Intimate History, which argued for a Freudian explanation of Jefferson's sexual activity with Hemings.  But some of Brodie's reasoning turned on speculative scenarios with little supporting evidence.

Finally, in 1997, the intellectual tide among historians began to turn towards accepting the story of Hemings as Jefferson's concubine because of the influence of Annette Gordon-Reed's book Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings: An American Controversy.  A historian with a law degree, she conceded that there was no "definitive proof" for this conclusion, but then she presented a carefully crafted legal brief claiming that the preponderance of the evidence favored it.

She summarized the evidence as eight items supporting the assertion that Thomas Jefferson fathered Sally Hemings's children .

1. Madison Hemings Claim to Be the Son of Thomas Jefferson.
Against the argument of historians that the abolitionist editor of the Pike County Republican (S. F. Wetmore) prompted Madison Hemings in 1873 to falsely claim to be the son of Jefferson, Gordon-Reed pointed out that as early as the 1840s there were newspaper reports about Madison and his brother Eston being the children of Jefferson.  Moreover, much of what Madison Hemings said in his interview with Wetmore has been confirmed by and fits with other evidence.

2. Israel Jefferson's Corroboration of Madison Hemings's Statement.

3. John Hartwell Cocke's Statement That Jefferson Had a Slave Mistress.
John Hartwell Cocke served with Jefferson on the Board of Visitors of the University of Virginia.  Cocke saw Jefferson's taking a slave concubine as manifesting an unwritten social code of conduct among slaveholders, who informally agreed that this practice would not damage one's public reputation as long as the slave master did not live openly with his slave concubines.  Historians have confirmed that this was in fact a widespread cultural norm (Morgan 1999; Rothman 1999).

4. James Callender's Assertion Corroborating Madison Hemings's Statement.

5. Hemings's Conceptions and Jefferson's Proximity.
This is one of the strongest pieces of evidence--that Hemings never conceived a child when Jefferson was not in residence at Monticello, although he was often away from Monticello for six to eight months at a time.  It is hard to understand how the Carr brothers failed to father any children during these long periods when Jefferson was absent from Monticello.

6. The Resemblance of Sally Hemings's Children to Thomas Jefferson..
Remarkably, while Thomas Jefferson Randolph was trying to deny Thomas Jefferson's paternity of Hemings's children, he admitted that they all looked much like him.  If we accept this, then it is unlikely that Hemings's children were fathered by any of the white men who visited Monticello, because Randolph's claims about resemblance to Jefferson reduced the possible fathers to three men: Thomas Jefferson, Peter Carr, and Samuel Carr.

7. The Treatment of Sally Hemings's Children.
The best evidence for Madison Hemmings's report of a "treaty" that Sally Hemings negotiated with Jefferson as her condition for agreeing to become his concubine in Virginia is what happened to her children.  All four of her children were allowed to leave Monticello as free adults after they turned 21.  Jefferson freed no other slave in this way.  The very few that he freed were older men that had performed special services for him.  Harriet Hemings was the only female that he ever freed.  The treatment of the Hemings's children was also special in that they were all assigned private baby-sitters.  The records also show that all three of Hemings's sons were taught to play the violin--the instrument favored by Jefferson himself.

8. The Freeing of Sally Hemings.
After the death of Jefferson, his slaves were sold, but Sally Hemings was allowed to go free and to live with her sons Madison and Eston.  Jefferson's will did not specify this, which is understandable if he did not want to provide public written evidence for his special treatment of her.

The ninth piece of evidence--and perhaps the most dramatic form of evidence--came a year after the publication of Gordon-Reed's book.  In 1998, a genetic analysis published in Nature showed that there was a DNA match on the Y chromosome between a living male-line descendent of Eston Hemings and male-line descendants of Field Jefferson, a paternal uncle of Thomas Jefferson (Foster et al. 1998; Foster et al. 1999; Lander and Ellis 1998).  The researchers had to look at the male-line descendants of Field Jefferson, because Thomas Jefferson had no sons who lived to adulthood, and thus he left no male descendants.

Most  of the Y chromosome is passed intact from father to son.  But there are small regions of DNA that vary among individuals, so that Y chromosomes can be distinguished by the haplotype (the set of specific variants) that they carry.  The authors of this study found a rare haplotype in the Y chromosome of the descendants of Jefferson's paternal grandfather that matched that of Eston Hemings's descendant.

This was widely reported as conclusive proof that Thomas Jefferson was the father of Sally Hemings's children.  But as the authors of the report indicated, they could not completely rule out the possibility that some male-line descendant of Field Jefferson other than Thomas Jefferson fathered an ancestor of the presumed male-line descendant of Eston Hemings.  The men of Randolph Jefferson's family could have fathered Sally Hemings's children.  But the researchers believed the historical evidence made this possibility unlikely.

In 2000, the Thomas Jefferson Memorial Foundation--the owner of Jefferson's home at Monticello--issues a report concluding that Jefferson fathered at least one and perhaps all of Sally Hemings's children.

But then some scholars rejected this as an unfair and unproven assault on the moral reputation of Thomas Jefferson as one of the greatest of America's Founding Fathers.  A group of these scholars formed the Thomas Jefferson Heritage Society, which set up a Scholars Commission of senior scholars to reexamine all the evidence for and against Jefferson's paternity of Hemings's children.  There were 13 members of the Commission: Lance Banning, James Ceaser, Robert H. Ferrell, Charles Kesler, Harvey C. Mansfield, Alf J. Mapp, Jr., David N. Mayer, Forrest McDonald, Paul A. Rahe, Thomas Traut, Robert F. Turner, Walter E. Williams, and Jean Yarbrough.  They issued their report in 2001, and it was published as a book in 2011 (Turner 2011).

The majority of the Scholars Commission--12 of the 13 members--concluded that that the allegation that Thomas Jefferson fathered Sally Hemings's children was by no means proven and probably false. The one dissenting member--Paul Rahe--agreed that this allegation was not decisively proven, but he dissented in "believing it somewhat more likely than not that Thomas Jefferson was the father of Eston Hemings."  He was particularly impressed by two lines of evidence--first, the correlation between the beginning of Sally Hemings's pregnancies and Thomas Jefferson's times of residence at Monticello, and, second, the DNA evidence that Eston was fathered by a direct male descendant of Jefferson's grandfather.

How one weighs the evidence in this case, Rahe observed, depends a lot on what one thinks about Jefferson's moral character.  Those scholars who find the story of Jefferson taking Hemings as his slave concubine incredible think this contradicts the moral character that he displayed throughout life. But those like Rahe who see evidence that Jefferson was unusually vain, deceitful, self-deceptive, and hypocritical are more inclined to see the story as credible.

After all, Rahe pointed out, we know for sure that even if Jefferson did not himself abuse his power as slaveholder over Sally Hemings, he allowed one or more members of his extended family to exercise abusive power over Hemings.

"In his private, as in his public, life," Rahe said, "there was, for all his brilliance and sagacity, something dishonest, something self-serving and self-indulgent about the man" (2011, 352).

I agree with Rahe.

Consider now how any explanation of this Jefferson-Hemings affair must move through the three levels of biopolitical science.  At the level of the universal history of the species, we have to explain the evolved psychology of human nature that supports male dominance hierarchies, the expression of dominance in enslavement, and the resistance of slaves to exploitative mastery.

In his original draft of the Declaration of Independence, Jefferson recognized that slavery was ultimately a "cruel war against human nature itself."  And in the Notes on the State of Virginia, he warned that "the whole commerce between master and slave is a perpetual exercise of the most boisterous passions, the most unremitting despotism on the one part, and degrading submissions on the other," and he saw that "the man must be a prodigy who can retain his manners and morals undepraved by such circumstances" (Jefferson 1982, Query XVIII, p. 162).  It appears that Jefferson was not such a prodigy.

At the level of the cultural history of the group, we can explain Jefferson's use of Hemings as his concubine, but without public acknowledgment, as his adoption of an informal social norm that arose in the culture of Virginia's slave society.  But in the Declaration of Independence and in other writings where Jefferson denounced slavery as unjust in violating the principles of natural right, we can see the cultural symbolism of Lockean liberal ideas and how those ideas contradict Jefferson's practice of slaveholding.

Finally, at  the level of the individual history of animals in the group, we have to judge Jefferson's personal character and his individual moral and political judgments.  Before Jefferson left for Europe in 1784, he consistently proposed plans for the gradual emancipation of slaves.  Yet when he returned to the United States in 1789, he continued to declare slavery a great injustice, but he never again proposed any plans for emancipation.  Scholars have wondered how to explain this change of mind.  Did it have something to do with Hemings's concubinage?  And if so, can we condemn him for his hypocrisy and deceit?

Jefferson's hypocrisy is most evident when he warns that if the American slaves are emancipated, they must be expelled from the country so that they are "removed beyond the reach of mixture" (Jefferson 1972, Query XIV, p. 143).  He worried about the "degradation" coming from the "amalgamation" of races (Jefferson 1984, 1345).  Alexander Hamilton criticized Jefferson for these comments, pointing out the high incidence of race mixing in slave societies because of slave masters making concubines of their slaves.


REFERENCES

Brodie, Fawn. 1974. Thomas Jefferson: An Intimate History.  New York: Norton.

Foster, Eugene A., M. A. Jobling, P. G. Taylor, P. Donnelly, P. de Knijff, Rene Mieremet, T. Zerjal, and C. Tyler-Smith. 1998. "Jefferson Fathered Slave's Last Child." Nature 396: 27-28.

Foster, Eugene A., et al. 1999. "The Thomas Jefferson Paternity Case." Nature 397: 32.

Gordon-Reed, Annette. 1997. Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings: An American Controversy. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.

Gordon-Reed, Annette. 2008. The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family.  New York: Norton.

Gordon-Reed, Annette. 2018. "Sally Hemings Takes Center Stage."  The New York Times. June 15.

Jefferson, Thomas. 1972. Notes on the State of Virginia. Ed. William Peden. New York: Norton.

Jefferson, Thomas 1984. Writings. Ed. Merrill D. Peterson. New York: The Library of America.

Lander, Eric S., and Joseph J. Ellis. 1998. "Founding Father." Nature 396: 13-14.

Morgan, Philip D. 1999. "Interracial Sex in the Chesapeake and the British Atlantic World, c. 1700-1820." In Sally Hemings and Thomas Jefferson: History, Memory, and Civic Culture, eds. Jan Ellen Lewis and Peter S. Onuf, pp. 52-84. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press.

Neiman, Fraser D. 2000. "Coincidence or Causal Connection? The Relationship between Thomas Jefferson's Visits to Monticello and Sally Hemings's Conceptions."  The William & Mary Quarterly 57: 198-210.

Rahe, Paul. 2011. "Minority Views of Professor Paul A. Rahe." In The Jefferson-Hemings Controversy: Report of the Scholars Commission, ed. Robert F. Turner, pp. 345-52. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.

Rothman, Joshua D.  1999. "James Callender and Social Knowledge of Interracial Sex in Antebellum America." In Sally Hemings and Thomas Jefferson, 87-113.

Stockman, Farah. 2018. "Monticello Is Done Avoiding Jefferson's Relationship With Sally Hemings.:" The New York Times. June 16.

Turner, Robert F., ed.  2011. The Jefferson-Hemings Controversy: Report of the Scholars Commission. Durham, NC: Carolina Academic Press.

Monday, July 06, 2020

Should the Jefferson Memorial Be Torn Down?



In today's New York Times, there is an article by Lucian Truscott IV, a descendant of Thomas Jefferson, who argues that the Jefferson Memorial in Washington should be taken down and replaced with a memorial for Harriet Tubman.  Although Jefferson deserves to be honored for declaring that "all men are created equal" and endowed with the rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, he should be condemned for not doing more to abolish slavery and for his shameful taking of Sally Hemings, his slave, as his concubine, who bore him six children.  The best monument to Jefferson, Truscott says, is Monticello, which includes an exhibit of Sally Hemings's bedroom, so that visitors can be reminded of Jefferson's hypocrisy and deceitfulness.

I have written about the evidence for Jefferson having made Hemings his concubine.  I have also written about Jefferson's biological science of equality, race, and slavery.

I conclude from this that Jefferson really did make the best scientific argument for human equality and the injustice of slavery, but that he lacked the good moral character to resist the degrading effects of owning slaves.

In his original draft of the Declaration of Independence, Jefferson recognized that slavery was ultimately a "cruel war against human nature itself."  And in the Notes on the State of Virginia, he warned that "the whole commerce between master and slave is a perpetual exercise of the most boisterous passions, the most unremitting despotism on the one part, and degrading submissions on the other," and he saw that "the man must be a prodigy who can retain his manners and morals undepraved by such circumstances" (Jefferson 1982, Query XVIII, p. 162).  Clearly, Jefferson was not such a prodigy.

Instead of taking down the Jefferson Memorial, wouldn't it provide great moral instruction to add a display at the Memorial explaining Jefferson's moral flaws as manifesting the degradation that Jefferson himself saw in the institution of slavery?  After all, Truscott agrees that Monticello is a properly instructive memorial to Jefferson precisely because of the Hemings display. 

If we are going to remove all of the public monuments for people who have any moral defects, then we will have no monuments at all.

Saturday, July 04, 2026

Can Americans Celebrate the Original Meaning of the Declaration of Independence?

 It is hard for me to celebrate this 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.  Because I assume that when Trump gives his speech today, he won't talk about the Declaration of Independence.  He will talk about himself--about how he's the greatest president and the most powerful human being who has ever lived.  I am old enough to remember the Bicentennial--July 4, 1976--when Gerald Ford was President.  He had become President in 1974 after Richard Nixon had resigned in disgrace.  In his Inaugural Address, Ford declared: "Our long national nightmare is over.  We are a government of laws and not of men."  Now the President of the United States brags that as President he has the power to do anything he wants to do.

To celebrate the Bicentennial, President Ford went to Philadelphia and delivered a long speech.  He didn't talk about himself.  Instead, he talked about the Declaration of Independence.  I knew something about his work on that speech because some of my professors at the University of Chicago, where I was a graduate student in political science, had been invited to the White House to talk with Ford about his speeches for the Bicentennial.

Last year, in an interview with ABC News, Trump was asked what he thought about the Declaration of Independence.  "Well, it means exactly what it says, it's a declaration," he said.  "A declaration of unity and love and respect, and it means a lot.  And it's something very special to our country."

A "declaration of unity"?  Hardly.  From the beginning the Declaration announces that it will "dissolve the political bands which have connected" the American colonies to Great Britain, and it becomes a declaration of war.  Of course, Trump wouldn't know that because he has never read the Declaration of Independence.

But there is a tradition of reading the Declaration of Independence on July 4th.  I remember well attending a Bicentennial party at George Anastaplo's house, where we took turns reading the Declaration aloud.  That tradition will be continued today at the National Archives in Washington, in Philadelphia, and elsewhere.

I hope that many Americans will carry on that tradition by reading not only the text of the Declaration but also some of the good books on the Declaration that have been published recently.  One of those is Steven Sarson's The Course of Human Events: The Declaration of Independence and the Historical Origins of the United States (University of Virginia Press, 2025).  

Sarson raises the question of whether the Declaration is to be celebrated today.  Most of us would probably say yes, of course, we should celebrate the Declaration for its proclamation of universal equality and liberty in the most famous section of the Declaration ("We hold these truths to be self-evident . . .").  But Sarson argues that to understand the original meaning of the Declaration for those who signed it, we need to read this second paragraph of the Declaration in the context of the whole document.  If we do that, he claims, we will see that the opening words--"When in the Course of human events"--introduce a universal history of humanity that begins with the Creation of man in the state of nature, moves through the British immigration and settlement of the American colonies, through the colonial debates over British rule in America, and then finally to American independence.  

In that history, Sarson asserts, we will see that yes originally all men were created equal and free in the state of nature and endowed with unalienable rights.  But then governments were instituted to secure those rights.  And whenever government fails to secure those rights, it is "the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness."

We will then see that the American people in the colonies decided that their safety and happiness required that they enslave Africans and wage war against "the merciless Indian Savages."  This made it clear that the American people did not believe that their governments should secure the equal natural rights of slaves and Indians.

Sarson explains:

The authors of the Declaration of Independence never intended that the self-evident truths of equality and unalienable rights be indiscriminately applied under the government and law of the United States.  Absolute equality and liberty existed in the state of nature. . . . But the social contract nevertheless required that perfect natural equality and liberty be abandoned in civil government and society. . . . For although the authors of the Declaration meant that all people were created equal as self-sovereign individuals and with equal endowments of rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, they did not mean that all were born with equal natural or civil capacities or competencies.  Some were men, some were not.  Some were white, some were not.  Some were economically independent, some were not.  Some were intelligent, educated, industrious, sober, and generally virtuous, some were not.  Most of the founders believed that these inequalities of capacity and competence should translate into civil governance and law. . . . In short, the authors of the Declaration of Independence envisioned a natural law republic that would secure the safety and happiness of its own citizens, not a natural rights republic that would institute equality and liberty for all (207-208).

Sarson says that this Declaration of Independence as it was originally understood by its signers is not worth celebrating because it supported a governmental system that denied the human rights of slaves, women, poor people, and Indians.  But within a few years after the Declaration was issued, many Americans--particularly those arguing for the abolition of slavery--stressed the "self-evident truths" of the second paragraph and interpreted the Declaration as a charter for universal equality and liberty.  That Declaration is worth celebrating, Sarson says, but only if we understand that what we're celebrating contradicts the original meaning of the Declaration. 

Sarson agrees with those historians who criticize the signers of the Declaration of Independence for denying that government should enforce equal liberty for all people.  But there's a clever twist in Sarson's reasoning because he argues that the Declaration of Independence does affirm equal natural rights--but only in the state of nature before the institution of government.  Because once human beings enter civil society, become "one people," and establish government, it is "the Right of the People" to recognize that human beings are unequal in their natural and social capacities and traits, and therefore they will have unequal roles in society.  Some will be masters because they are white Europeans, and others will be slaves because they are black Africans.  Men will take the leading roles in society, while women will be assigned to the domestic roles of wife and mother.  The Europeans will expand their territorial claims on the American continent by expelling the American Indians from the western territories.  Thus it is the right of the American people to deprive some people of their life, their liberty, and their pursuit of happiness if that is necessary for the safety and happiness of the American people.

I disagree.  I think that when we celebrate the Declaration as teaching that just government must secure the natural rights of equal liberty for all people under that government, we really are celebrating the original meaning of the Declaration.  Even though that securing of natural human rights is never fully achieved, it does constitute what Abraham Lincoln called "the standard maxim for a free society" that can be approximated over time.

In support of that conclusion, I have argued that denying the equal liberty of slaves, women, and American Indians violates the principles of the Declaration of Independence.

There are lots of weaknesses in Sarson's arguments for his reading of the Declaration.  But here I'll point only to the most obvious one.  If the interpretation of the Declaration as a promise of equal liberty for all men is mistaken, because that's not how it was understood by those who wrote and signed the Declaration, then we would expect that the signers of the document would have corrected this mistaken interpretation.  In particular, Thomas Jefferson and John Adams lived exactly 50 years after the Declaration was first issued because amazingly they both died on July 4, 1826, the 50th anniversary of the Declaration.  So Jefferson and Adams had 50 years in which they could have corrected the mistaken interpretation of the Declaration advanced by the abolitionists.  But while Sarson quotes extensively from the founders, he cannot quote any remark from the founders that makes this correction.

There was one occasion in particular where Jefferson could have made this correction, and he didn't.  Benjamin Banneker (1731-1806) was a distinguished African-American mathematician and scientist.  He was the child of a free black mother and a formerly enslaved father from Africa.    In 1791, he was appointed to the surveying team that laid out the District of Columbia.  In the same year, he wrote a long letter to Jefferson, who was then the Secretary of State.

In that letter, Banneker condemned slavery as an unjust violation of "the rights of human nature."  He also thought that Jefferson had clearly seen "the injustice of a state of slavery" when he wrote the Declaration of Independence: 

it was now Sir, that your abhorrence thereof was so excited; that you publicly held forth this true and invaluable doctrine, which is worthy to be recorded and remembered in all succeeding ages.  "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, and that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."

But then he accused Jefferson of contradicting these principles of equal liberty "in detaining by fraud and violence so numerous a part of my brethren under groaning captivity and cruel oppression, that you should at the same time be found guilty of that most criminal act which you professedly detested in others, with respect to yourselves."  Banneker attributed this to Jefferson's "narrow prejudices" about black people.  

Banneker did not know that after the death of his wife in 1782, Jefferson had made one of his slaves--Sally Hemings--his concubine, beginning in 1787 when Sally was 16 and Jefferson 46.  He carried on a thirty-eight-year connection to Hemings that produced seven children, four who lived to adulthood.  Jefferson publicly condemned interracial sex.

Along with his letter, Banneker enclosed a copy of his Almanac that he had just prepared, which showed his impressive knowledge of mathematics and astronomy.

Here is Jefferson's letter in response:

No body wishes more than I do to see such proofs as you exhibit, that nature has given to our black brethren, talent equal to those of the other colours of men, and that the appearance of a want of them is owing merely to the degraded condition of their existence both in Africa and America.  I can add with truth that no body wishes more ardently to see a good system commenced for raising the condition both of their body and mind to what it ought to be, as fast as the imbecility of their present existence, and other circumstances which cannot be neglected, will admit.--I have taken the liberty of sending your almanac to Monsieur de Condorcet, Secretary of the Academy of sciences at Paris, and member of the Philanthropic society because I considered it as a document to which you whole colour had a right for their justification against the doubts which have been entertained of them.

Both of these letters were published as a separate pamphlet in Philadelphia in 1792.

If Sarson were right in his interpretation of the original meaning of the Declaration of Independence, then we would expect Jefferson to explain to Banneker that the natural rights to equal liberty apply to the state of nature but not to civil society, and that it is "the Right of the People" to establish a government that deprives slaves of their natural rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.  But Jefferson says nothing like that.  He is just silent about Banneker's interpretation of the Declaration as declaring the injustice of slavery.

Sarson says nothing about Banneker's letter and Jefferson's response.  And so he does not allow his reader to see that Jefferson refused to take the opportunity to confirm Sarson's interpretation of the Declaration of Independence.

To me that's clear evidence that Sarson's interpretation of the Declaration distorts its original meaning as understood by Jefferson and others.  

That means that we can celebrate the Declaration of Independence today as originally understood by the American founders as a charter of human liberty and equality.

And we need not be distracted by Trump's celebration of himself.

Tuesday, November 08, 2022

Partisan Polarization and the Threat of Civil War in America's Most Dangerous Election: The Election of 1800

The partisan polarization in this American election was so intense that it became a political war.  Many people expected the country would fall into a violent civil war.  There were charges of voting irregularities that were part of a conspiracy to steal the election.  The party in control of the national government had used the force of the government to suppress freedom of speech by arresting their political opponents and charging them with sedition.  State legislatures controlled by one party claimed that they had the power to select their state's presidential electors without allowing a popular vote.  Those state legislatures that did allow the popular election of presidential electors found ways to rig the counting of the popular votes to favor the candidate preferred by the legislature.  

This was the election of 1800.  President John Adams was running for reelection as the leader of the Federalist Party.  Adams's opponent was Vice-President Thomas Jefferson, who was running as the leader of the Republican Party.  The election became a triumph for the Republicans, who took control of both the House and the Senate in the Congress.  Jefferson was elected President, but only after a deadlock in the Electoral College threw the outcome of the presidential election into the House of Representatives.  Oddly, Jefferson and his running mate Aaron Burr had received an equal number of votes for president in the Electoral College.  After taking 36 rounds of voting over a week's time, the House finally voted for Jefferson.  Later, Jefferson called this the "Revolution of 1800."  

Some historians have identified this as the first time in history that a popular election brought the peaceful transfer of power between parties who detested one another.  But even if it ultimately turned out to be peaceful, the election was turbulent, and it expressed enraged political passions that could easily have broken out into a bloody civil war.  And, of course, 60 years later, in the election of 1860, another turbulent election did lead to the American Civil War.

Now that Americans have once again been divided by vicious passions of political polarization, it is time to study the election of 1800 to see if it gives us any lessons about how to prevent political party competition from becoming a political civil war.  (Of the many scholarly studies of that election, one of the best is John Ferling's Adams vs. Jefferson: The Tumultuous Election of 1800 [Oxford University Press, 2004].)


THE LOVE OF FAME AND PRESIDENTIAL AMBITION

The roots of the partisan split between the Federalists and the Republicans originated in the factional rivalry within George Washington's presidential administration (1789-1797).  Adams was the Vice-President.  Alexander Hamilton was the Secretary of the Treasury.  Jefferson was the Secretary of State.  All four of these men had a passion for fame, and thus all four wanted to be the President, because, as Hamilton had said in Federalist Number 72, the American presidency was designed to appeal to those moved by "the love of fame, the ruling passion of the noblest minds."  All four saw the American Revolution and the American Founding as providing them the opportunity for becoming famous as statesmen founding a new form of government.  In 1777, Adams told Richard Henry Lee: "You and I, my dear friend, have been sent into life at a time when the greatest lawgivers of antiquity would have wished to live.  How few of the human race have ever enjoyed an opportunity of making election of government . . . for themselves or their children."

Although all four sought the fame of becoming great statesmen, they disagreed about what was the best form of statesmanship.  In a letter to Benjamin Rush in 1811, Jefferson related a story from the days of Washington's administration.  Jefferson had invited Hamilton and Adams to dine at his lodgings to discuss some matters that needed to be resolved.  After the discussion was over, they turned to casual conversation.  Hamilton asked Jefferson about the portraits hanging in Jefferson's room.  Jefferson told him that these were pictures of the three greatest men in the history of the world--Francis Bacon, Isaac Newton, and John Locke.  Hamilton paused for some time, and then said: "The greatest man that ever lived was Julius Caesar."  Since Caesar had overthrown the Roman Republic, Jefferson took this as confirming his suspicion that Hamilton wanted to overturn the American Republic so that he could become a new Caesar ruling over an American Empire.

In that same conversation, according to Jefferson, Adams and Hamilton got into a discussion of the merits and defects of the British constitutional monarchy.  Adams thought that that if the defects were removed, this could become the best form of government.  But Hamilton thought that even with its defects, it was still the best form of government.  This indicated to Jefferson that they were both monarchists: Adams wanted a reformed monarchic republic that would balance the three orders of society (the one, the few, and the many), while Hamilton wanted a monarchic republic in which the president would be an elected monarch with a lifetime term in office.  Jefferson thought that Hamilton had revealed his monarchic plan of government in his speech at the Constitutional Convention on June 18, 1787.

Jefferson saw here a contrast between the Anglophilic attachment to the British monarchic form of government and his own attachment to the radically democratic and anti-monarchic politics of the French Revolution.  When war broke out between Great Britain and France, this provoked a division in Washington's administration between those Federalists who favored Great Britain and those like Jefferson who took the side of France.  This dispute continued under the presidential administration of Adams, who was elected president in 1796, with Jefferson as his Vice-President.

This political disagreement over what position the U.S. should take in the war between Great Britain and France led to an acrimonious debate in the party press, with Republican-supported newspapers attacking Adams and the Federalists as monarchists and Tories who wanted to overturn the American Revolution.  These attacks from the newspapers provoked the Ultra-Federalists in the Congress into passing the Alien and Sedition Acts in the summer of 1798.  The Sedition Act provided for fines up to $5,000 and jail terms of up to five years for those who uttered or published "any false, scandalous, and malicious" statement against the United States government or its officials.  This was a blatant violation of the First Amendment's declaration that "Congress shall make no law . . . abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press."  The Federalist newspapers demanded this.  For example, John Fenno of the Gazette of the United States declared: "It is patriotism to write in favor of government--it is sedition to write against it."  Sedition and seditious libel were criminal offenses under the English common law, but the Jeffersonian Republicans argued that such a law violated American Republican liberty.  This was one of the major issues in the election of 1800.  In 1799, Matthew Lyon, a Vermont Republican congressman, was reelected while serving jail time after being convicted under the Sedition Act.


BALANCING THREE SOCIAL ORDERS 

From his survey of political history and political philosophy, Adams had concluded that every society shows three social orders--the one, the few, and the many.  First, in every society, there must be a "first magistrate" or "principal personage."  Some one person of sufficient talent and ambition will rise to the top of society.  He might be a "great genius" or a "masterly spirit," who draws all eyes to himself.  Second, there must also be a small group of people whose influence elevates them to some aristocratic preeminence based on wealth, noble birth, or other abilities that make them the center of public attention.  Third, the great majority of people will generally defer to the rule of the dominant leader and the preeminent few unless they feel so oppressed that they resist or even overthrow their superiors.  These three social orders can be based on inherited positions as in the eighteenth-century British social class system of monarchs, nobles, and commoners.  But even in America, where there is no such hereditary order of classes, Adams observed, there can still be a constitutional arrangement of offices that reflects these three orders.  

Adams thought that these three social orders--one leader, an ambitious few who want to rule, and many others who defer to the ruling few but who don't want to be oppressed--could be seen not just in human societies but in the societies of other political animals.  I have written about this evolved political psychology of dominance, deference, and counter-dominance among political primates.

Adams thought that a constitutional republic like the United States could achieve a balance of the three social orders that would be free from violent disorder and despotic rule.  But achieving this would require constitutional procedures by which disputes over the positions of leadership could be settled in a peaceful and orderly way through popular elections.  The election of 1800 suggested, however, that the constitutional procedure for electing the president through the Electoral College was not an effective way to do this.


THE FAILURE OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE

One of the most complicated and confusing debates at the Constitutional Convention of 1787 was over how to elect the President.  The delegates finally decided on having the President selected by an Electoral College.  But the first two contested presidential elections--in 1796 and 1800--exposed the flaws in the Electoral College procedures--flaws that have continued to create problems for presidential elections throughout American history.

Here's the text from Article II, Section 1, of the Constitution:

"Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress . . . ."

"The Electors shall meet in their respective States, and vote by Ballot for two Persons, of whom one at least shall not be an Inhabitant of the same State with themselves.  And they shall make a List of all the Persons voted for, and of the Number of Votes for each; which List they shall sign and certify, and transmit sealed to the Seat of the Government of the the United States, directed to the President of the Senate [who is the Vice President].  The President of the Senate shall, in the Presence of the Senate and House of Representatives, open all the Certificates, and the Votes shall then be counted.  The Person having the greatest Number of Votes shall be the President, if such Number be a Majority of the whole Number of Electors appointed; and if there be more than one who have such Majority, and have an equal Number of Votes, then the House of Representatives shall immediately chuse by Ballot one of them for President; and if no Person have a Majority, then from the five highest on the List the said House shall in like Manner chuse the President.  But in chusing the President, the Votes shall be taken by States, the Representation from each State having one Vote; A quorum for this Purpose shall consist of a Member or Members from two thirds of the States, and a Majority of all the States shall be necessary to a Choice.  In every Case, after the Choice of the President, the Person having the greatest Number of Votes of the Electors shall be the Vice President.  But if there should remain two or more who have equal Votes, the Senate shall chuse from them by ballot the Vice President."

For many years, I taught courses on American Government and American Constitutional Law for college students; and I regularly assigned my students to read this constitutional text in preparation for a class discussion of what it means.  Every time I did this, I found that almost all of the students found this text to be incomprehensible.  Moreover, I have found that most American citizens generally cannot understand this; and so they cannot understand how their presidents are elected.  Isn't that enough to justify amending the Constitution to strike out this section and replace it with a simple statement of how the President and Vice President should be elected by a national popular vote?

At the beginning, everyone assumed that George Washington would be the first President, and no one would dare to challenge him; and so it was easy for the Electoral College to select him for two terms.  But then by the end of Washington's second term, a two-party system had emerged, which had not been foreseen by the constitutional framers.  James Madison offered the first explanation of this new party system in an article ("A Candid State of Parties") for the Republican newspaper National Gazette on September 26, 1792.  He claimed that there had been three party systems in America.  First, during the American Revolution, one political party was comprised of those people who supported the Revolution, while the other party was comprised of the Loyalists or Tories who opposed the Revolution.  The second party system arose during the ratification debates over the Constitution of 1787--one party supporting ratification of the new Constitution (the Federalists) and another opposing it (the Anti-Federalists).

Finally, the third party system emerged during Washington's presidency; and this third division "being natural to most political societies, is likely to be of some duration in ours."  On the one side, are those people who favor the rule of those with wealth and high rank, because they think "mankind are incapable of governing themselves."  On the other side, are those who believe "that mankind are capable of governing themselves," and that hereditary power is an outrage to the rights of man.  It's the party of the few (the antirepublican party) against the party of the many (the Republican party).  Madison suggests that this is "natural to most political societies" because of the natural propensity of human beings to divide themselves into the privileged few and the common multitude.

Of course, Hamilton and Adams refused to be identified as "anti-republican."  One might say that the contest was between three kinds of republicanism.  The oligarchic republicanism of Hamilton, the balanced republicanism of Adams, and the democratic republicanism of Jefferson.

In any case, once Washington had announced his political retirement, the presidential elections of 1796 and 1800 became politically polarized elections contested by the Federalists led by Adams and Hamilton and the Republicans led by Jefferson and Madison.  In 1796, the Republicans in the Congress agreed to support Jefferson for President and Aaron Burr for Vice President; the Federalists in Congress endorsed Adams for President and Thomas Pinckney for Vice President.  In 9 of the 16 states, the electors in the Electoral College were chosen by the state legislature rather than popular vote.  There were 136 presidential electors in the 16 states.  Adams received 71 votes, which was just one vote over the 70 required for a majority.  Jefferson received 68 votes, so he became Vice President.  This strange outcome--a Federalist President and a Republican Vice President--resulted from the fact that the Constitution required the electors to cast two votes without distinguishing between a vote for President and a vote for Vice President.

In 1800, the Federalist Congressmen agreed to support Adams for President and Charles Cotesworth Pinckney for Vice President; and the Republican Congressmen again supported Jefferson for President and Burr for Vice President.

One Republican newspaper (Aurora, October 14, 1800) listed the differences between the parties as viewed by the Republicans (Ferling, p. 148):


Federalist

1.   Condemned the principles of 1776

2.   Monarchist

3.   Bent on war with France

4.   Hatred of the people

5.   Had made victims of new immigrants

6.   Inaugurated an economic bonanza for the affluent

7.   Supporters of established churches

8.   Increased the public debt and taxes

9.   wished to meddle in Europe to preserve the balance of power

10. Used the Sedition Act to destroy a free press

11. Favored an established church and powerful priesthood


Republican

1.   Longed to restore the principles of the Revolutionary patriots

2.   Foes of monarchy

3.   Wished peace with the world

4.   Appealed through reason to the people

5.   Prefer equal laws for all citizens and would-be citizens

6.   Would call to account those who plunder the public

7.   Would separate church and state

8.   Favored a reduction of both taxes and the public debt

9.   With Washington, prefers not to meddle in Europe's affairs

10. Favored freedom of the press

11. Favored religious freedom


State legislatures chose the presidential electors in 11 of the 16 states.  In those 5 states with popular voting, the state legislatures could influence the outcome by altering how the popular votes were counted--for example, whether it was a winner-take-all system across the state, or whether the votes would be counted by congressional districts.

On election day--December 3--as required by the Constitution, the electors met in each state and cast two votes, one of which had to be for someone outside their state.  Although the slate of electors was chosen by the parties, the electors are not required by the Constitution to keep their pledge to support their party's nominees.  In 1796, about 40% of the electors departed from their party's recommendations.  In 1800, only one elector of 138 broke ranks.

With 138 electors, a majority would be 69.  When the electoral votes were counted, Jefferson and Burr tied at 73, while Adams had 65, and Pinckney had 64.  Consequently, according to the Constitution, the House of Representatives would have to decide whether Jefferson or Burr was the president, with each state congressional delegation casting one vote.  

The House met on February 11, 1801, with Inauguration Day, March 4, only three weeks away.  Of the 16 states, the Republicans controlled 8 delegations (New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Kentucky, and Tennessee), the Federalists controlled 6 (New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Delaware, and South Carolina), and 2 were deadlocked (Maryland and Vermont).

There were secret machinations in which the Federalists negotiated with Jefferson and Burr to see which one would give them the best deal in exchange for their votes for president.  Jefferson and Burr were being asked to promise that the Federalists would have some control over policies or appointments in the new presidential administration.  After 33 ballots over four days, the deadlock was not broken.  There were rumored threats from Jeffersonian Republicans that they would use force if Jefferson was not selected, or that Virginia would secede from the Union.  At the same time, there were rumors that there was a conspiracy to assassinate Jefferson.  Later, Adams said that "a civil war was expected" during this time.

Finally, after 36 ballots over a week's time, Jefferson was elected.  Although Jefferson publicly denied it, it was generally believed that he had agreed to some kind of bargain with the Federalists for their votes.

At the Inauguration, March 4, Jefferson delivered an eloquent inaugural speech stating his principles and attempting to reconcile the party divisions--declaring "we are all republicans, we are all federalists."  Adams was not at the inauguration, because he had left Washington hours before to return to his home in Massachusetts.  Adams and Jefferson would never meet again for the next quarter century.  They would die on the same day--July 4, 1826.


THE CORRUPTION OF AMERICAN POLITICS BY SLAVERY

The elections of 1796 and 1800 showed a sectional split: the Federalists were stronger in the North, the Republicans stronger in the South.  This split was rooted in slavery.  Adams had never owned slaves, and he condemned slavery as a violation of the equal liberty affirmed by the Declaration of Independence.  Jefferson owned many slaves, and while he admitted that slavery was wrong, he made no effort to abolish slavery.  The Federalists--particularly Hamilton--scorned Jefferson for the hypocrisy of affirming equal natural rights while owning slaves.  Moreover, Jefferson would not have won the election of 1800 without the Constitutional provision that counted 3/5 of the slaves towards state representation in the Congress.

In 1798, Jefferson and Madison wrote the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions that affirmed the sovereignty of the states and the right of the states to nullify national laws, which would become the basis for the Southern nullification and secession movement to protect slavery in the South that would lead to the Civil War.

The moral corruption that comes from slavery was particularly evident in Jefferson's case because he took one of his slave women--Sally Hemings--as his concubine.  As I have indicated in a previous post, there is plenty of evidence that Jefferson was the father of Hemings' children, and that his sexual use of her began when she was 16 years old, and he was 46.  It is also clear that Hemings' father was Jefferson's father-in-law, and so she was the half-sister of Jefferson's wife Martha.

In the election of 1800, there were rumors of this.  Then, beginning in 1802, some Federalists openly condemned Jefferson for this.  Jefferson refused to say anything about it.

In some ways, the legacy of slavery in America continues to corrupt American politics through polarizing debates over Black Lives Matter, the 1619 Project, Critical Race Theory, and the White Supremacist Movement.


CHRISTIAN NATIONALISM AND JEFFERSON'S ATHEISM

We can also see in the election of 1800 the political polarization over whether America should be seen as a Christian Nation.  In the election, some ministers preached sermons warning that Jefferson was an infidel or an atheist, and therefore Christians should not elect him President.  For example, John Mitchell Mason, regarded as one of the greatest pulpit orators of his day, delivered a sermon in 1800 with the title "The Voice of Warning to Christians, on the Ensuing Election of a President of the United States," and it was widely circulated as a pamphlet.  

From his reading of Jefferson's Notes on the State of Virginia, Mason found four kinds of evidence for Jefferson's atheism.  First, Jefferson denied the truth of Noah's Flood by claiming that such a universal flood over the Earth was "out of the laws of nature."  Second, Jefferson's account of the differences in the human races seemed to deny the common origin of mankind in Adam and Eve.  Third, Jefferson implied that there was never a "chosen people" of God.  Fourth, he denied that religious belief was necessary for social order, because he said that "it does me no injury for my neighbors to say there are twenty Gods or no God.  It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg."  This passage from the Notes on Virginia was often quoted by many Federalists as evidence that Jefferson was an "infidel" or atheist.

Mason admits that "the federal Constitution makes no acknowledgment of that God who gave us our national existence," but that means that "to wipe off the reproach of irreligion," Christians must be careful not to elect an atheist like Jefferson.  Mason conceded that Washington and Adams were hypocrites who vaguely professed some religious belief without being true Christians.  But still, he argued, it was better for Christians to vote for a hypocrite like Adams than an atheist like Jefferson, because at least hypocrisy does not directly challenge the identity of America as a Christian Nation.

The question of whether we should recognize America as a Christian Nation or should affirm the separation of church and state continues today to disrupt American political debate.  The Trump Republicans have insisted that the Democrats want to expunge America's Christian tradition.  As I have said in a previous post, some of the Republicans have claimed that Trump is "God's Chosen One."  And a few days ago, Ron DeSantis's campaign organization broadcast a video claiming that DeSantis had been specially created by God--on the eighth day of Creation!--to be the "fighter" for true Americans.


                                                      And God Created Ron DeSantis


THE PHILOSOPHIC FRIENDSHIP OF ADAMS AND JEFFERSON OVERCOMES POLITICAL POLARIZATION

As I have said, once Jefferson was inaugurated president in 1801, he and Adams never met again for the rest of their lives.  They did not even write letters to one another until 1812.  But in that year, they resumed their correspondence; and from 1812 to 1826, when they both died, they exchanged over 150 letters.  In my post on this correspondence, I have noted the deep philosophic topics that came up in this correspondence.  Adams and Jefferson had competed for political fame, and Adams left office resentful that Jefferson had become the more famous one, particularly in claiming to be the author of the Declaration of Independence.  But in this correspondence over the last 14 years of their life, having retired from politics, Adams and Jefferson could resume their philosophic friendship, and in doing that, rise above politics and the pursuit of political fame.

Amazingly, Jefferson and Adams both died on the 50th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence--July 4, 1826.  As the news spread across America, this was seen as a remarkable, perhaps even providential, sign that these two men, who had been so long divided by their partisan political rivalry, were ultimately united in common death and immortal fame as Founding Statesmen of America.

Thursday, June 21, 2018

Evolution by Hybridization of a New Species of Galapagos Finches from a Founding Father

                                                     The Big Bird Finch of the Galapagos

Last year, in one of my posts on my second tour of the Galapagos Islands, I wrote about the evolution of new species through hybridization, including the report from Peter and Rosemary Grant that there might be a new species of finch on the island of Daphne Major arising from hybridization, although they had not yet said that this really was a new species.

Recently, the Grants have published their claim that this is indeed a new species that has evolved through hybridization (Lamichhaney et al. 2018; Wagner 2018).  In 1981, a male large cactus finch (Geospiza conirostris) arrived on Daphne Major, having immigrated a long distance (over 100 km) from the island of Espanola, the only island where this species is found.  They called him "Big Bird" because of his unusually large head.

Big Bird mated with a medium ground finch (G. fortis).  This pair produced offspring, and with only one exception, the offspring found mates descended from the original pair, thus breeding within the hybrid lineage, for over 30 years.  Because of their larger body size, they are called Big Birds.  So, as with the biblical story of Adam and Eve, we have a new species derived from a founding pair of mates.

Large cactus finches learn the distinctive song of their species by listening to their fathers sing, which is thus passed down through a culturally learned tradition.  The first Big Bird--the founding father--sang a unique song, slightly different from the song sang by male large cactus finches on Espanola.  This is the song now sung by male Big Birds, and it contributes to their reproductive isolation.

Another cue for reproductive isolation is that the size of the Big Birds' bill is intermediate between the bill sizes for the other species, which is probably a consequence of natural selection favoring a bill morphology adapted for feeding on certain kinds of seeds on Daphne Major.

Genetic analysis has confirmed that the Big Birds are a distinctive species separate from the other 18 species of finches on the Galapagos Islands.

Notice the historical contingency in this scientific study.  The rare and chance event of one individual bird with a unique song immigrating to Daphne Major and mating with a female of a different species, in the unique circumstances of that island at a particular historical moment, became a founding event for the evolution of a new species.

This illustrates the historical character of biology as the study of unique individuals with unique life histories and cultural traditions.  It is not true, therefore, that human beings are the only animals who have individual and cultural histories.  A biopolitical science of political animals must include the study of the individual personalities and the social history of those animals.  (I have written about this here, and here.)

My next post will be devoted to another kind of hybrid breeding by a founding father--Thomas Jefferson's interracial breeding with his slave Sally Hemings.


REFERENCES

Lamichhaney, Sangeet, Fan Han, Matthew T. Webster, Leif Andersson, B. Rosemary Grant, and Peter R. Grant. 2018. "Rapid Hybrid Speciation in Darwin's Finches." Science 359 (12 January): 224-228.

Wagner, Catherine E. 2018. "Improbable Big Birds." Science 359 (12 January): 157-159.

Tuesday, September 08, 2020

Is the Declaration of Independence Proslavery, Antislavery, or Both?



The second night of the Republican National Convention (Tuesday, August 25) began with a video with an image of the Declaration of Independence and a narrator reading its most famous passage: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they ae endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness."

The narrator then explained:

"Without life, there can be no liberty.  Without liberty, there is no happiness.  Without equality, there is no opportunity."  [At this point in the video, there are pictures of Abraham Lincoln, Frederick Douglass, and Martin Luther King.]

 "America has strived since its founding to promote equality under the law, to correct injustices, and to ensure opportunity for all.  It is a work in progress, not always perfect."

"Some look at American opportunity and see only problems.  They want equal outcome, not equal opportunity."  [Here there are pictures of Charles Shumer, Nancy Pelosi, Kamala Harris, and Bernie Sanders.] 

"They criticize without solutions, demand wealth without work.  Their ways are historical failures evidenced by tyranny and poverty, a prevailing darkness in every country that it has been tried."  [Here there are images of the 1989 Tiananman Square protests in Beijing, Fidel Castro, and Che Guevara,]

"The American dream inspired by American opportunity is the engine of entrepreneurship, the inspiration with the greatest intentions." [Here there are pictures of Donald Trump.]

". . . Tonight, we explore together America, land of opportunity." 

Excerpts from this video were shown throughout the convention, and it set a persistent theme: the Republican Party is defending the principles of the American founding as stated in the Declaration of Independence--particularly, the principle of equality of opportunity--while the Democratic Party is attacking those principles and promoting the principles of socialist tyranny--particularly, the principle of equality of outcome.

The theme for the third day of the Convention was "Heroes of America."  South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem was the first speaker.  She warned that the founding principles of America were under attack, and that we must struggle to live up to those founding principles.  As part of this attack on the Founding, she observed, the Democrats are tearing down all the monuments to our American heroes.

Although I did not notice any explicit reference at the Republican Convention to the "1619 Project" of the New York Times, this was certainly in the background, because the complaint that America was founded on slavery by American leaders who were themselves slaveholders is central to what the Republicans see as the attack on America.  Just a few days ago, President Trump said that he would prohibit any federal funding to public schools that adopt material from the 1619 Project as part of their curriculum for teaching American history.

The Republicans see that America is "a work in progress, not always perfect," because equality of opportunity for all has never been perfectly achieved, but it is still worth striving for.  By contrast, we are told, the Democrats see only the imperfection and not the progress, and they conclude that America must strive for a socialist equality of outcome, although this will bring tyranny and poverty.

So is it true that the Declaration of Independence rightly promised a government that would secure equality of opportunity for all Americans, and that while never perfectly attained, this American dream of equal opportunity has been the proper standard by which we can see all of American history as showing progressive improvement in striving to achieve human equality in the natural rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness?  

Or has this been a failure--or only a partial success--because from the beginning, America was founded on slavery and white racism, which have denied full equality of rights for black Americans?  If it has been a failure, does that come from the racial tribalism that is rooted in the propensity to xenophobia or in-group bias that is part of our evolved human nature?  Do we see that racial tribalism today displayed in the violent street conflicts between "Black Lives Matter" protestors and their "Blue Lives Matter" opponents?

In her Pulitzer-Prize-winning article for the 1619 Project, Nikole Hannah-Jones wrote:

"The United States is a nation founded on both an ideal and a lie.  Our Declaration of Independence, approved on July 4, 1776, proclaims that 'all men are created equal' and 'endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights.'  But the white men who drafted those words did not believe them to be true for the hundreds of thousands of black people in their midst.  'Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness' did not apply to fully one-fifth of the country.  Yet despite being violently denied the freedom and justice promised to all, black Americans believed fervently in the American creed.  Through centuries of black resistance and protest, we have helped the country live up to its founding ideals.  And not only for ourselves--black rights struggles paved the way for every other rights struggle, including women's and gay rights, immigrant and disability rights."

.  .  .

". . . in making the argument against British tyranny, one of the colonists' favorite rhetorical devices was to claim that they were the slaves--to Britain.  For this duplicity, they faced burning criticism both at home and abroad.  As Samuel Johnson, an English writer and Tory opposed to American independence, quipped, 'How is it that we hear the loudest yelps for liberty among the drivers of Negroes?'"

"Conveniently left out of our founding mythology is the fact that one of the primary reasons some of the colonists decided to declare their independence from Britain was because they wanted to protect the institution of slavery.  By 1776, Britain had grown deeply conflicted over its role in the barbaric institution that had reshaped the Western Hemisphere.  In London there were growing calls to abolish the slave trade.  This would have upended the economy of the colonies, in both the North and the South.  The wealth and prominence that allowed Jefferson, at just 33, and the other founding fathers to believe they could successfully break off from one of the mightiest empires in the world came from the dizzying profits generated by chattel slavery.  In other words, we may never have revolted against Britain if some of the founders had not understood that slavery empowered them to do so; nor if they had not believed that independence was required in order to ensure that slavery would continue.  It is not incidental that 10 of this nation's first 12 presidents were enslavers, and some might argue that this nation was founded not as a democracy but as a slavocracy."

"Jefferson and the other founders were keenly aware of this hypocrisy.  And so in Jefferson's original draft of the the Declaration of Independence, he tried to argue that it wasn't the colonists' fault.  Instead, he blamed the king of England for forcing the institution of slavery on the unwilling colonists and called the trafficking in human beings a crime.  Yet neither Jefferson nor most of the founders intended to abolish slavery, and in the end, they struck the passage."

Notice the contradiction in Hannah-Jones' claims here.  She begins by saying that Jefferson and the other white men who drafted the words about human equality in the Declaration "did not believe them to be true for the hundreds of thousands of black people in their midst."  But then she says they "were keenly aware" of their "hypocrisy" in affirming natural human equality while denying the application of this principle to black slaves.  If the founders did not believe that black people were created equal to whites in their natural rights, then the founders could not have been guilty of hypocrisy, because hypocrisy here would mean refusing to recognize the human equality of black and white people that one knows to be true.

That Jefferson recognized the equality of blacks and whites, and thus the injustice of black enslavement, is evident in the passage in the original draft of the Declaration, to which Hannah-Jones refers, in which Jefferson condemned the slave trade as a "cruel war against human nature itself."  I have written about this in a previous post.  Here Jefferson repeated a charge that he had made in his Summary View of the Rights of British America (1774), where he complained that the efforts of Virginia and some other colonial legislatures to impede or stop the slave trade were vetoed by the King.  He observed that stopping the slave trade would be the first step towards abolishing slavery: "The abolition of domestic slavery is the great object of desire in those colonies, where it was unhappily introduced in their infant state" (Jefferson 1984, 115).

In the same passage of the original draft of the Declaration where Jefferson condemns the King for the slave trade, he also condemns the King for inciting the slaves to rebel against their American masters:  "he is now exciting those very people to rise in arms among us, and to purchase that liberty of which he has deprived them, by murdering the people on whom he also obtruded them: thus paying off former crimes committed against the LIBERTIES of one people, with crimes which he urges them to commit against the LIVES of another."

Although this passage was struck out of the final draft of the Declaration, the condemnation of the King's inciting slave rebellion was introduced into the last of the 27 grievances against the King: "He has excited domestic insurrections among us, and has endeavoured to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers the merciless Indian savages, whose known rule of warfare is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes, and conditions."

The American colonists were threatened not only by the "domestic insurrections" of the slaves from whom they had stolen labor, but also by the attacks of Indians from whom they had stolen land.  And, indeed, in the American Revolutionary War, the British stirred both the Indians and the slaves to fight against the rebels.  But many slaves chose to fight for the rebels.  American loyalists and rebels stole slaves from one another in the war.  During the war, as many as 100,000 slaves gained their freedom.  One might say that the American Revolution became the largest slave rebellion in American history.

Jefferson and the other leading American founders all agreed that slavery violated the principles of the Declaration of Independence, because slavery was wrong in denying the natural liberty and equality of the slaves, who had a natural right to overthrow the tyranny of their masters, just as the white American colonists had the right to overthrew the tyranny of the British.  They also agreed that slavery would have to be abolished, but they disagreed about how and when that should happen.

In the 20 years after 1776, 6 of the original 13 states abolished slavery.  In 1777, Vermont became the first to abolish slavery in its constitution.  In 1780, Pennsylvania adopted a law mandating the gradual emancipation of slavery--through the emancipation of slave children once they reached adulthood.  In 1781-1783, several Massachusetts court decisions found slavery incompatible with the state constitution (written by John Adams), which declared in 1780 that all men "are born free and equal."

But none of the Southern states succeeded in abolishing slavery.  In 1785, Jefferson said that people in the North were "jealous of their own liberties, and just to those of others," while people in the South were "zealous for their own liberties, but trampling on those of others" (Letter to Chastellux, September 2, 1785; Jefferson 1984, 827).

In June of 1776, Jefferson was on a committee to draw up plans for revising the laws of Virginia.  He proposed a plan for the gradual emancipation of slaves--the children of slaves would be freed at age 18 (for females) or 21 (for males), and then these newly emancipated blacks would be colonized somewhere outside of Virginia where they could live as a free and independent people.

Although Jefferson's plan for abolition was never adopted, in 1782, Virginia adopted a law that encouraged slaveholders to emancipate their slaves.  And in 1784-1785, there were proposals for the general emancipation of slaves.

But then, the General Assembly of Virginia received at least 5 petitions signed by over 1,500 people across Virginia who opposed both the manumission of slaves by slaveholders and any general emancipation.  

They made three arguments (Schmidt and Wilhelm 1973).  First, abolishing slavery was said to deny the natural rights of slaveholders to life and property, which was contrary to the Declaration of Independence.  Second, slavery was said to be supported by the Bible--both the Old Testament and the New Testament.  Third, emancipation was said to be bad policy, because freed blacks would commit "rapes, murders, and outrages" and would generally misbehave.

These Virginia petitioners in the 1780s were proslavery in the strong sense that they were arguing for slavery as a "positive good," which would become more common in the South in the 1830s, when people like John C. Calhoun would take this position.

Those American founders who were slaveholders--like Jefferson, Madison, and Washington--were proslavery only in the weak sense, in that while they recognized the injustice of slavery as violating the principles of the Declaration of Independence, they saw no way that slavery could be immediately abolished without disastrous consequences for the South.  They hoped that someday slavery could be abolished, and then the freed blacks could leave the United States and colonize some area in Africa or South America.  White settlers could then be imported as hired laborers to take the place of the slaves.

Jefferson did not think that a multiracial society in which blacks and whites would be socially and politically equal was possible.  In his Notes on the State of Virginia, he remarked:

"It will probably be asked, Why not retain and incorporate the blacks into the state, and thus save the expense of supplying, by importation of white settlers, the vacancies they will leave?  Deep-rooted prejudices entertained by the whites; ten thousand recollections, by the blacks, of the injuries they have sustained; new provocations, the real distinctions which nature has made; and many other circumstances, will divide us into parties, and produce convulsions which will probably never end but in the extermination of the one or the other race" (1984, 264).

Did Jefferson himself share those "deep-rooted prejudices" of the whites? In 1791, while he was Secretary of State under President Washington, Jefferson received a letter from a free black man accusing him of just that.  Benjamin Banneker was a polymath--a surveyor, a poet, and a student of mathematics and astronomy--who had just published an almanac.  He sent Jefferson a long letter along with a copy of his almanac as evidence for black intelligence.  He said that when Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence affirming the equal rights of human nature, he "clearly saw into the injustice of a state of slavery." But then he observed that Jefferson's selfish interests in slaveholding--"in detaining by fraud and violence so numerous a part of my brethren"--had allowed his moral judgment to be blinded by "narrow prejudices" (Basker 2012, 131).

Remarkably, Jefferson responded with a short letter of only five sentences, in which he said: "No body wishes more than I do to see such proofs as you exhibit, that nature has given to our black brethren, talents equal to those of the other colors of men, and that the appearance of a want of them is owing merely to the degraded condition of their existence."  He passed over in silence Banneker's charge of "narrow prejudices."

We know now that when this correspondence occurred in 1791, Jefferson had taken his slave Sally Hemings as his concubine.  He sired at least four children by her.  After he started this sexual relationship with Sally (while he was in Paris, 1787-1789), Jefferson never again spoke about his plans for abolishing slavery.  I have written about this in a previous post.

In his Notes on Virginia, Jefferson had written about the morally degrading effects of slavery--both for the master and for the slave.  Do we see that in Jefferson himself?

Even if we see in Jefferson the moral flaws that delayed the abolition of slavery in the United States, we also see in Jefferson's Declaration of Independence the principles of human liberty and equality that demanded that abolition.  Perhaps this shows us that America really is "a work in progress, not always perfect."

But how much progress have we achieved?  The abolition of slavery through the Civil War and the Civil War constitutional amendments and then the breaking up of Jim Crow segregation through the Civil Rights Movement surely count as great progress.  But when we look at the intense conflicts provoked by the Black Lives Matter movement, we must wonder whether we have failed to completely overcome the racial tribalism that Jefferson thought would always prevent full racial equality in a multiracial free society.

I have written about the evolution of racial/ethnic identity (here and here).

 

REFERENCES

Basker, James G., ed.  2012. American Antislavery Writings.  New York: The Library of America.

Jefferson, Thomas. 1984. Writings. Ed. Merrill D. Peterson. New York: The Library of America.

Schmidt, Fredrika Teute, and Barbara Ripel Wilhelm. 1973. "Early Proslavery Petitions in Virginia." William and Mary Quarterly 30: 133-146.