Trump's Extended Interview with Ross Douthat for "60 Minutes"
For only $1,000, you could have purchased the President Donald J. Trump Signature Bible with Trump's hand-written signature inside the front cover. Unfortunately, these Bibles are sold out. But don't cry, because you can still purchase The Presidential Edition Bible "Commemorating the 45th and 47th Presidency of the USA Donald J. Trump" for only $99.99, although it doesn't have Trump's signature. This Bible has the King James Version of the Bible and copies of the handwritten chorus to "God Bless the USA" by Lee Greenwood, the US Constitution, the Bill of Rights, the Declaration of Independence, and the Pledge of Allegiance.
These Bibles were printed in China and shipped to the United States at a cost of $3 each. Trump's 2025 financial disclosure included royalty payments amounting to $1,300,000 for his endorsement of this Bible produced by Lee Greenwood.
For many evangelical Christians this is proof that Trump is not only a Christian but a Christian Nationalist who recognizes that America was founded as a Christian Nation, and that Trump has been chosen by God to save America's Christian heritage from the attacks of the anti-Christian Democrats.
That raises lots of questions. If Trump is a true Christian, does that mean that his Christian faith makes him secure in his salvation, and so he will go to Heaven? But if he is unsure about whether he is going to Heaven or Hell, does that suggest he is not a believing Christian?
What bearing do our answers to these questions have on the idea of America as a Christian Nation? Does a Christian Nation require a Christian President? Or is it enough that God has chosen Trump to save America, even though Trump is not a Christian, just as God chose the pagan Persian Cyrus as the "messiah" or "anointed one" to liberate the Children of Israel from their Babylonian captivity? Or does the separation of church and state and the "no religious test" clause of the Constitution mean that we cannot enforce a profession of Christianity or any religious belief for the officers of government including the President or for the citizens?
If America is in some sense a Christian Nation, what exactly does that mean? Does that include the liberal Christianity of people like Roger Williams and James Talarico? Or is it restricted to the illiberal Christianity of people like John Winthrop and Ken Paxton?
Does the Bible give us any clear answers to these questions? Or is the Bible too obscure to give us any clear answers to such questions?
The first set of questions--concerning Trump's eternal destiny after death--were raised by Ross Douthat in his "60 Minutes" interview of Trump.
TRUMP "BEFORE THE JUDGMENT THRONE OF GOD"
At about 48 minutes into Douthat's interview (the extended interview on YouTube), Douthat says: "Let's talk about death." Trump says: "Okay." Douthat suggests that Trump's surviving multiple assassination attempts--one coming very close to killing him--must have had some effect on how he thinks about mortality. Trump says: "Yeah." Douthat then asks: "What do you think happens when you die?"
"Well, I hope I'm missed," Trump answers. Douthat responds by suggesting that Trump has misunderstood the question: "No, I mean--I mean to you." But Trump repeats his answer: "No, but I really mean it. I hope I'm missed. . . . I think I've done a good job as--I--I--." Douthat rephrases his question four or five times: "What do you think happens to Donald Trump when you die? . . . Not your memory, yourself." Finally, Trump understands his question: "Okay. You mean where I go?" "Exactly," Douthat says.
"Well, I'm a religious person," Trump responds, "so in theory I go to Heaven." Douthat asks: "Do you think you're going to Heaven?" And Trump answers: "I hope so. I don't want to go to Hell."
Douthat then reminds Trump of Charlie Kirk's memorial service, at which Erica Kirk, his widow, "gave some very moving remarks about Christian forgiveness, how you have to forgive your enemies and your opponents," and therefore she said that she had forgiven the young man who murdered Charlie.
Douthat then reminds Trump of what he said after Erica Kirk's remarks:
And you followed her, and you said, and I know this was a little bit of a joke, but I think facts come through jokes. You said, quote, "I hate my opponents, and I don't want the best for them." Let's say you pass away, you're entering the next life, and all you have to do to enter Paradise is feel love and forgiveness for James Comey, Nancy Pelosy, anyone who you have expressed hate for over the years. Do you think you can do it?
Trump responds: "I found them to be extremely dishonest people, very bad people, very bad for our country."
Douthat asks: "Is the answer no then?"
Trump answers: "The answer is no."
"Before the judgment throne of God?" Douthat asks.
"Before the judgment," Trump responds. "No, I think they were very bad people and--I dislike, I can use the word hate, I do hate some of my enemies. I think they're--they've been terrible."
Douthat presses him: "You are telling me you couldn't find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that's been given you?"
Trump refuses to budge: "I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies, and I always will."
Douthat then turns to one last question. "Lots of presidents are remembered for a single line. 'He freed the slaves.' 'He won the Cold War.' A hundred years from now, as you're working out your situation in Purgatory, what's the line that your presidency is remembered for?"
Trump's answer: "That I made America great again."
Notice that when asked about "what happens when you die?," Trump's first response is to hope that he will be missed and that he will be remembered for the good things he did. This is what I have called (following Stephen Cave) "the legacy narrative" for life after death. There are four possible ways that we might achieve immortality. The Staying Alive Narrative says that we could become immortal if we could find a way to postpone death indefinitely. The Resurrection Narrative says that even if death is unavoidable, we might be brought back to life. The Soul Narrative says that even if our bodies must die, our souls can live forever because they are immaterial and thus not subject to bodily decay, and our souls are the most essential part of us. Finally, the Legacy Narrative says that we can live on after death through those that live after us--either because they remember us or because they carry our genes. Trump wants to be alive after death through being remembered as a great president who "made America great again."
But as Douthat suggests in the interview, our memory of Donald Trump after his death will preserve a copy of Donald Trump but not the living personal reality of Donald Trump. Douthat wants to know whether Trump believes that he will live on after death--Donald Trump the person. And for a Christian like Douthat, that means either the "soul narrative" or the "resurrection narrative" or both at different stages. So for many Christians, one traditional view is that after we die, our souls live on separated from our dead bodies, but then later our bodies are resurrected and joined to our souls to form what Paul called "spiritual bodies" that live forever either in Hell or in Heaven after they have faced the Last Judgment.
Finally, then, Douthat gets Trump to say: "I'm a religious person, so in theory I go to Heaven," and he hopes to go to Heaven because "I don't want to go to Hell."
Strangely, Trump does not say that he is a Christian, but rather he says he's a "religious person," and every religious person "in theory" goes to Heaven; and his fear of Hell makes him hope that he will go to Heaven instead. Is Trump implying that there is no single true religion because all religious people--Muslims, Hindus, Jews, and others--can be saved and go to Heaven?
Douthat doesn't raise this question. Instead, he continues his questioning as if they agree that Christianity is the only religion that sets the standards for going to Heaven or Hell. He implies that Erica Kirk was correct in interpreting Jesus as teaching that we must love our enemies and forgive them if we want to be saved and enter heaven. He suggests that when Trump dies, he will go "before the judgment throne of God," and the one requirement to enter paradise will be to feel love and forgiveness for his enemies. So when Trump says, "I do hate some of my enemies and I always will," even facing God's judgment, that would seem to mean--at least by Douthat's standards--that Trump is going to Hell.
This also implies that those liberal Democrats like James Talarico who teach "love thy neighbor" are more likely to go to Heaven than Trump and the Trump Republicans who teach "hate thy neighbor."
But then, at the end of the interview, Douthat reverses direction and suggests that Trump will be saved and enter Heaven! He suggests this by his framing of his last question for Trump: "A hundred years from now, as you're working out your situation in Purgatory . . . ." As a Catholic, Douthat believes in the Catholic doctrine of Purgatory, which is poetically depicted in Dante's Purgatorio. According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, Purgatory is for people "who die in God's grace and friendship, but still imperfectly purified, are indeed assured of their eternal salvation" (para. 1030).
But in suggesting that Trump will "die in God's grace," Douthat contradicts the Catholic Church's teaching about the conditions for receiving God's grace as stated in the Catechism:
Death puts an end to human life as the time open to either accepting or rejecting the divine grace manifested in Christ [cf. 2 Tim 1:9-10]. The New Testament speaks of judgment primarily in its aspect of the final encounter with Christ in his second coming, but also repeatedly affirms that each will be rewarded immediately after death in accordance with his works and faith. The parable of the poor man Lazarus and the words of Christ on the cross to the good thief, as well as other New Testament texts speak of a final destiny of the soul--a destiny which can be different for some and for others [cf. Lk 16:22; 23:43; Mt 16:26; 2 Cor 5:8; Phil 1:223; Heb 9:27; 12:23].
I see no evidence that Trump by "his works and faith" has accepted "the divine grace manifested in Christ." On the contrary, his scorn for Jesus' teaching "love thy neighbor" and his refusal to ask forgiveness for his sins show that he has rejected the divine grace necessary for salvation. Douthat is wrong, therefore, to suggest that Trump will go to Heaven once he has passed through Purgatory.
After all, if Trump is going to be saved, then everybody is going to be saved. Well, maybe that's what Douthat is implying--that Purgatory offers everyone the chance to have their souls purified and then go to Heaven. In that case, Douthat would be a "universalist" who believes that God wants everyone to be saved.
As I have noted in some previous posts, Christian universalists have identified at least 23 texts supporting their view that while some human beings will endure a period of punishment in Hell, ultimately all human beings will be saved and enter Heaven. There are some clear doctrinal statements in the New Testament of God's intention to save all human beings. "So, then, just as through one transgression came condemnation for all human beings, so also through one act of righteousness came a rectification of life for all human beings" (Romans 5:18). "For just as in Adam all die, so also in Christ all will be given life" (1 Corinthians 15:22). "Our savior God . . . intends all human beings to be saved and come to a full knowledge of truth" (1 Timothy 2:3).
But then there are some scriptural texts about Hell as eternal torment, such as Revelation 20. John foresees that Christ will return to earth to rule over all the earth for a thousand years. At the end of that thousand-year reign, there will be a judgment of Satan, who will be thrown into a lake of fire and "tormented day and night for ever and ever." Then, there will be a judgment of the dead, and "each person was judged according to what they had done." "Anyone whose name was not found written in the book of life was thrown into the lake of fire."
These apparently contradictory texts manifest the fundamental problem for scriptural interpretation: the Bible is so obscure that it is almost aways open to diverse interpretations on important matters of doctrine. And so here the Bible gives us no clear standards for supporting Trump, his presidency, or the appeals to Christian nationalism made by the Trump Republicans.
On the other hand, the obscurity of the Bible supports a Lockean liberal Christianity that teaches toleration, religious liberty, and the separation of church and state, thus rejecting Christian nationalism. As I have argued previously, the obscurity of the Bible and the failure of the Holy Spirit to convey the correct interpretation of the Bible creates a religious pluralism among Christians that supports John Locke's liberal theology of Christianity--that since "everyone is orthodox to himself," and "every Church is orthodox to itself," there is no set of universal doctrines binding on all Christians, except perhaps the belief that Jesus is the Messiah; and therefore, there is no one Christian orthodoxy strictly speaking that can be properly enforced by government.
For this reason, a Lockean liberal social order that secures religious liberty and religious toleration is the best regime for promoting the pluralistic pursuit of religious happiness. It does this by creating a marketplace of religion in which churches compete for customers, and those churches that best satisfy the desire for religious experience increase their share of the market. Moreover, as Locke argued, this is what one sees in the New Testament: the early Christian churches were voluntary associations that did not coercively enforce a single orthodoxy on all believers. It was not until late in the 4th century A.D. that the Roman Emperors enforced the orthodoxy of the Catholic church and punished Christian heretics.
TRUMP AS CYRUS? OR NEBUCHADNEZZAR?
Similarly, as I have argued, the Bible does not clearly sustain the claim of the Christian nationalists that Trump is God's chosen one--just like Cyrus--even though Trump might be a pagan unbeliever. In Isaiah 45, God was using Cyrus as His "anointed one" to allow the Israelites to leave Babylon and return to Jerusalem where they could restore the Mosaic theocracy under the Davidic monarchy. But the New Testament set aside this Old Testament theocracy and established the Christian churches as voluntary organizations--as Roger Williams argued against John Winthrop. So there is no parallel between Trump and Cyrus.
We should also notice that God used the pagan leader Nebuchadnezzar as "the servant of the Most High God" to punish Judah by taking them into the very Babylonian captivity from which Cyrus would later liberate them (Jeremiah 25). So if God is using Trump, we can't be sure whether Trump is to be America's savior (like Cyrus) or America's punishment (like Nebuchadnezzar). And indeed many Christians who have refused to vote for Trump worry that the Christians supporting Trump are showing a shameless lack of moral authority. Is God punishing these Christians for their hypocrisy?
Has God used Trump's evil rule to provoke the rise of liberal Christian politicians like Senator Talarico, who promote the Christian politics of "love thy neighbor" against Trump's anti-Christian politics of "hate thy neighbor"?
If that were so, then, in a strange sort of way, Trump really is Making America Great Again--by turning America away from Trump's politics of hate back towards America's politics of love.
