Douglas Wilson Speaks at the Pentagon
On Tuesday, November 17th, Pastor Douglas Wilson delivered a sermon at the Pentagon at Pete Hegseth's invitation. Wilson seems to be the leading proponent of American Christian theocracy, who has apparently persuaded not only Hegseth but other leaders in the Trump Administration to promote the establishment of a Christian theocracy in America. In this sermon, he argues that the defeat suffered by "our side" in the midterm elections should not be seen as a final defeat for Christian theocracy, because God has promised that inevitably Christians will rule over America and even over all the nations of the world.
But careful readers of Wilson's writings about Christian nationalism will see that he never clearly advocates anything like Puritan theocracy, and he hints that his secret teaching rejects theocracy and supports the Lockean liberalism of religious liberty and toleration.
COMPARING THE REPUBLICAN MIDTERM DEFEAT TO THE CRUCIFIXION OF CHRIST
In his Pentagon sermon, Wilson speaks for "our side" in these "hyperpartisan times," as "Conservative Christians" who are accused by their enemies of wanting to impose the morality of Christian theocracy. But, in fact, Wilson argues, all societies are theocracies in some sense.
You have perhaps been accused of wanting to bring in a theocracy. But again, not whether but which. All societies have a point past which there is no appeal, and when you get to that point you have identified the god of that system. All societies have a theos. In Muslim societies, it is Allah. In Christian societies, it is the Father of Jesus Christ. In secular societies, it is Demos, the people. In confused and muddled societies, it is CNN.
Do you see his hint of a joking word play here? The Democrats want a secular society where the Demos elects Democrats to rule them, as in the midterm elections. But those Conservative Christian Trump Republicans who want God to rule America need not despair over these elections:
God is in the process of building the largest triumphal arch ever built, and every stone in it was taken from the quarry that is located in the Valley of Disaster. So why should the believing Christian despair over the condition of this world--midterms or no midterms? The potter uses clay. The carpenter uses wood. The painter uses brushes and paint. God is the supreme artist, and His raw material of choice is death.
Just imagine the disciples of Christ, the day after the crucifixion, huddled and hidden in that upper room of theirs. When they reflected on the day before, the day Christ died, it was impossible to see it as anything other than the worst day in the history of the world. The only perfect man who ever lived had just been judicially murdered by a sleek and arrogant aristocracy. And what happened on that day? Your forgiveness and mine were purchased on that day. The salvation of the world was accomplished on that day.
I mentioned at the first the direction we are going. That direction was set when Jesus died. "And I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto me" (John 12:32). The direction the gospel points to is the salvation of the world, and the gathering in of all the nations of the world. The earth will be as full of the knowledge of the Lord as the waters cover the sea (Is. 11:9). That is where we are going.
In short, the worst day in the history of the world was the best day in the history of the world. God draws straight with crooked lines.
. . .
Take heart. We are right on schedule.
Notice the implied parallel between God's metaphorical Triumphal Arch and Trump's planned Triumphal Arch. This sounds like Trump is a divine instrument of God. When Wilson was questioned about this, he didn't deny that this was his suggestion. "I was referring to God's metaphorical arch," he replied. "But I had Trump's little human arch in the background of my mind."
Notice also the implied parallel between the crucifixion of Christ and the defeat of the Trump Republicans in the midterm elections. The disciples of Christ saw His crucifixion as the worst day in the history of the world, not realizing that God would make it the best day in the history of the world, because it would accomplish the salvation of the world. Similarly, Trump Republicans think their loss of the midterms is the worst day in the history of America, not realizing that God will make it the best day in the history of America, because it will somehow fit into God's plan for the salvation of America.
WILSON'S "THEOCRATIC LIBERTARIANISM"
But what exactly does Wilson mean by his prediction that America and all the world will eventually come to God for salvation? Many people have assumed that he means that first America and then other societies will become Christian theocracies in which Christianity will be coercively enforced by law as the established religion. I have argued, however, that Wilson's "theocratic libertarianism"--his term--is not really theocratic at all. His secret teaching is a Lockean liberal Christianity that tolerates religious pluralism, in which "each man is orthodox to himself," and "each church is orthodox to itself."
Much of what he has said and written points to this as his true teaching. For example, he has said that sins should not be punished as crimes. And so, for instance, while homosexuality is a sin, it should not be punished as a crime. Moreover, he has said that in the United States, there should be no legal establishment of religion at either the national or state level.
What Wilson has called his "Boniface Option" is simply a slightly more aggressive "Benedict Option," in which Christians organize themselves into voluntary groups that promote Christianity, but without seeking the political power to coercively enforce theocratic rule over others.
Another way to put this is that ultimately Wilson takes the side of Roger Williams' liberal Christianity in colonial Rhode Island against John Winthrop's illiberal Christianity in the Massachusetts Bay Colony.
Surprisingly, this also means that Wilson takes the side of James Talarico against the Christian nationalism promoted by Texas Republican leaders, although I doubt that Wilson would ever publicly admit this.

No comments:
Post a Comment